Skip to content
To take full advantage of this site, please enable your browser's JavaScript feature.
Learn how
WEBSITE NAVIGATION
Home
Shop
Paint
Milwaukee Tools
Products & Services
Contact
14485 Greene Street NE, Palmyra, Indiana 47164
CALL:
812-364-6675
Blue River Farm Supply Online Store
Shop Our Categories
Website
Catalog
View cart
Home
Shop
Paint
Milwaukee Tools
Products & Services
Contact
Product Categories
HAND TOOLS
STRIKING AND CUTTING TOOLS
TRADESMAN TOOLS
MEASURING & MARKING
MECHANICS TOOLS
SAFETY & ORGANIZATION
CLAMPS / FASTENING TOOLS
POWER TOOLS & ACC
POWER TOOLS
POWER TOOL ACCESSORIES
PNEUMATIC TOOLS & ACCESSORIES
POWER EQUIPMENT
POWER NAIL GUNS & STAPLERS
FASTENERS
NAILS, TACKS, BRADS
NUTS, BOLTS, SCREWS
CHAIN, CABLE, ROPE
METAL SHAPES & STOCKS
HARDWARE
LOCKSETS & KEYING SUPPLIES
WINDOW & DOOR HARDWARE
GENERAL HARDWARE
BUILDERS HARDWARE
CONSTRUCTION HARDWARE
PAINT & SUNDRIES
PAINT
PAINT APPLICATORS /ACCESSORIES
SUNDRIES
DECORATING
ELECTRICAL
LIGHT BULBS
LIGHTING & CEILING FANS
ROUGH ELECTRICAL
HOUSEHOLD ELECTRICAL
SPECIALTY ELECTRICAL
PLUMBING
KITCHEN & BATH
ROUGH PLUMBING SUPPLIES
HEATING & COOLING
FIREPLACE & ACCESSORIES
HEAT & AIR CONDITIONING
VENTING & FANS
HOUSEWARES
CLEANING SUPPLIES
KITCHENWARE
HOUSEHOLD PRODUCTS
HOME DECOR AND ACCENTS
LAWN & GARDEN
LAWN & GARDEN TOOLS
LAWN POWER EQUIPMENT
LAWN CARE
LANDSCAPE SUPPLIES
SNOW & ICE REMOVAL
PET & WILD BIRD
WILD BIRD / SQUIRREL SUPPLIES
SMALL ANIMAL
DOG & CAT SUPPLIES
FARM & RANCH
HORSE CARE & SUPPLIES
CATTLE CARE & SUPPLIES
LIVESTOCK CARE & SUPPLIES
POULTRY CARE & SUPPLIES
BEEKEEPING
FARM EQUIPMENT
FENCING
AUTOMOTIVE
GENERAL AUTOMOTIVE
RV & MOBILE HOME SUPPLIES
OUTDOOR LIVING & PATIO
OUTDOOR LIVING & ACCESSORIES
SWIMMING POOLS & EQUIPMENT
SPORTING GOODS
SPORTS EQUIPMENT
MARINE, HUNTING & CAMPING
Nav Menu 4
Nav Menu 5
Nav Menu 6
Nav Menu 7
Nav Menu 8
Home
>
PLUMBING
>
KITCHEN & BATH
>
TOILET REPAIR
>
TANK BALLS / FLAPPERS
Sort By:
Price: Low to High
Price: High to Low
Most Popular
Title
Manufacturer
Newest
Oldest
Availability
90 per page
180 per page
360 per page
1
Worldwide Sourcing PMB-185-3L Toilet Flapper, For Use With Kohler Toilet Tanks, Rubber
Our Price:
$2.83
Worldwide Sourcing PMB-198 Universal Toilet Tank Ball, For Use With Toilet Valves, Rubber
Our Price:
$2.86
Worldwide Sourcing 24462-3L Toilet Tank Flapper and Chain
Our Price:
$2.96
Lavelle 525BP Replacement Universal Toilet Flapper, For Use With Crane Flush Valves, Vinyl
Our Price:
$3.64
Danco 88762 Self-Align Universal Toilet Tank Ball, Rubber
Our Price:
$3.78
Danco 80813 Toilet Tank Ball, 2-1/2 in, Rubber, For Use With Eljer Touch-Flush Unit
Our Price:
$3.87
Danco 80800 Universal Toilet Tank Ball, Plastic, Black
Our Price:
$3.97
Danco 80807 Universal Toilet Tank Flapper With Attachment Chain, Rubber, For Use With All Standard Flush Valves
Our Price:
$3.98
Danco 80808 Universal Toilet Tank Flapper With Adapter, Rubber, For Use With All Standard Flush Valves
Our Price:
$4.22
Fluidmaster 5052GBP4 Universal Toilet Tank Flapper, 2 in, Plastic
Our Price:
$4.26
Plumb Pak PP23503 Chemical Resistant Universal Flapper Tank Ball With Strap and Hook, For Use With Most Flush Valves
Our Price:
$4.36
Worldwide Sourcing PMB-189 Toilet Flapper, For Use With Kohler Toilet Tanks, Rubber
Our Price:
$4.37
Worldwide Sourcing PMB-192 Toilet Tank Ball With Lift Wire, Rubber
Our Price:
$4.40
Plumb Pak PP835-2 Universal Toilet Tank Ball, Rubber
Our Price:
$4.54
Sure-Fit 503 Universal Toilet Flapper, For Use With Flush Valves With or Without Mounting Ears
Our Price:
$4.56
Fluidmaster 500 Universal Tank Ball Toilet Flapper
Our Price:
$4.71
FLAPPER TANK KOHLER/AMERLINE
Our Price:
$4.84
Plumb Pak PP835-3 Universal Flapper Tank Ball With Trunnion and Integral Chain, Vinyl, Black
Our Price:
$4.96
Plumb Pak PP836-00 Chemical Resistant Toilet Flapper, For Use With Kohler Rialto Toilets, Vinyl
Our Price:
$5.02
Korky 425BP Tank Ball, For Use With Eljer Touch Flush Assembly, Chlorazone Rubber, Red
Our Price:
$5.20
Danco 88353 Premium Toilet Tank Flapper, 2 in, Rubber, For Use With All Standard Flush Valves
Our Price:
$5.22
Korky Plus 2001BP Toilet Flapper, For Use With Brass and Plastic Flush Valves, Chlorazone Durable Rubber, Red
Our Price:
$5.33
Plumb Pak PP835-38 Self-Aligning Universal Toilet Tank Ball With Lift Wire, For Use With Toilet Master Tank, Rubber
Our Price:
$5.36
Plumb Pak K836-46-5 Toilet Tank Flapper With Hook, For Use With 2 in Flush Valve Assembly, Vinyl, Blue
Our Price:
$5.40
Danco 88686 Toilet Tank Flapper, Rubber
Our Price:
$5.44
Fluidmaster 501CT/P21 Replacement Flapper Tank Ball, Rubber
Our Price:
$5.61
Danco 88442 Premium Toilet Tank Flapper, 2 in, Rubber, For Use With All Flush Valves
Our Price:
$5.67
FLAPPER FIT K-HINGE
Our Price:
$5.73
FLAPPER FIT KOHLER/SHARK FIN
Our Price:
$5.73
Plumb Pak PP835-80 Universal Toilet Flapper With Chain and Hook, For Use With Plastic Flush Valves, Rubber
Our Price:
$5.86
FLAPPER FIT KOHLER/RIALTO
Our Price:
$5.89
Plumb Pak PP835-81 Toilet Tank Ball, For Use With Eljer Toilet Tank, 2-3/8 in, Rubber
Our Price:
$5.93
Sure-Fit 504 Universal Toilet Flapper, For Use With Flush Valves With or Without Mounting Ears
Our Price:
$5.96
FLAPPER TOILET TANK UNIVERSAL
Our Price:
$6.09
Plumb Pak PP23646 Chemical Resistant Premium Quality Toilet Flapper With Chain and Hook, Rubber
Our Price:
$6.27
Plumb Pak PP835-67 Dome Toilet Flapper With Chain and Hook, For Use With Kohler Toilets, 5/16-18 X 3 in, Rubber
Our Price:
$6.27
FLAPPER KIT F/KOHLER
Our Price:
$6.29
Plumb Pak PP23580 Universal Toilet Flapper With Chain and Hook, Rubber, Black
Our Price:
$6.33
Korky Plus Classic Toilet Flapper, For Use With Older Style Brass Flush Valves, Chlorazone Rubber
Our Price:
$6.35
Korky Plus 2004BP Adjustable Toilet Flapper, For Use With Kohler and American Standard Toilet Tanks
Our Price:
$6.46
Fluidmaster 502CT/P21 Adjust-A-Flush Toilet Flapper, For Use With Most 1.6 gal Toilets, 2 in
Our Price:
$6.52
Danco 88662 Premium Toilet Tank Flapper, Natural Rubber, For Use With Kohler Toilet Models
Our Price:
$6.69
Korky 100BP Chlorine Resistant Toilet Flapper, For Use With 1.28, 1.6, 3.5 and 5 gpf Toilets, 2 in, Rubber, Red
Our Price:
$7.12
Fluidmaster 5051 Universal Toilet Flapper, Rubber, For Use With 1.6 gal per Flush Toilets and Most 2 in Flush Valves
Our Price:
$7.12
FLAPPER HYDRO 3IN REPLACEMENT
Our Price:
$7.18
FLAPPER WATER SAVER 13418
Our Price:
$7.32
Danco 88875 Premium Toilet Tank Flapper, Rubber
Our Price:
$7.67
Danco 88246 Toilet Tank Flapper, Rubber, For Use With Kohler Wellworth Lite and Sterling Windham
Our Price:
$7.73
Plumb Pak K833-3 Chemical Resistant Universal Toilet Tank Flapper With Chain and Hook, For Use With 3 in Flush Valve
Our Price:
$7.94
Danco HFL190 Adjustable Toilet Tank Flapper, 2 in, Silicone Rubber
Our Price:
$8.04
Lavelle 2011BP Hinge, Replacement Toilet Flapper, For Use With Kohler 1-Piece Toilets, Red
Our Price:
$8.13
Lavelle 2010BP Float, Replacement Toilet Flapper, For Use With Kohler 1-Piece Rialto Toilets, Red
Our Price:
$8.13
Lavelle 2012BP Replacement, Shark Fin Toilet Flapper, For Use With Kohler 1-Piece Toilets, Red
Our Price:
$8.13
Korky 58BP Flush Ball Flapper, For Use With Kohler 2-Piece Toilets, Chlorazone Rubber, Red
Our Price:
$8.59
Danco 88497 Toilet Tank Flapper, Rubber, For Use With American Standard Toilets
Our Price:
$8.66
Danco 88874 Premium Toilet Tank Flapper, Rubber, Teal
Our Price:
$8.98
Plumb Pak PP835-89 Toilet Flapper With Chain and Hook, For Use With Eljer Lowboy Toilet, Plastic
Our Price:
$9.13
Touch Flush 88017 Flush Valve, For Use With All Eljer Conventional Closet Tank
Our Price:
$9.18
FLAPPER ADJUST 3IN
Our Price:
$10.18
Plumb Pak K833-1 Chemical Resistant Toilet Flapper With Silicone Seal, For Use With 3 in Toilet Flush Valve, 3 in
Our Price:
$10.55
Fluidmaster 5401GBP4 Adjustable Universal Toilet Tank Flapper, 3 in, Rubber
Our Price:
$10.63
Titan 3030BP Replacement Toilet Flapper, For Use With Eljer Toilets, 3 in Valve Opening, Rubber
Our Price:
$10.72
Danco 88763 Water Saving Flapper, Rubber, For Use With 1.6 Gal Low-Flush Toilet
Our Price:
$10.74
Class Five 3010BP Replacement Toilet Flapper, For Use With Kohler 1016546 and 1042313 Toilet Tank
Our Price:
$11.28
Danco 88500 Toilet Tank Flapper, 3 in, Rubber, For Use With Eljer Titan Toilets
Our Price:
$11.28
Danco 88503 Toilet Tank Flapper, 3 in, Rubber, For Use With Mansfield Toilets
Our Price:
$11.28
FLAPPER HIGH PERFORMNC RED 2IN
Our Price:
$11.42
FLAPPER UNIVERSAL PREMIUM 3PK
Our Price:
$11.79
Danco 88502 Toilet Tank Flapper, 3 in, Rubber, For Use With Kohler Class Five Toilets
Our Price:
$11.84
Worldwide Sourcing 070990 Eljer Style Flush Valve, PVC
Our Price:
$11.86
Danco 10764 Toilet Flapper, For Use With American Standard Cadet 3 Toilets, 3 in, Plastic, White
Our Price:
$12.66
Danco 88501 Toilet Tank Flapper, 3 in, Rubber, For Use With Kohler Cimarron Toilets
Our Price:
$13.05
Korky 3060BP Adjustable Universal Toilet Flapper, For Use With Large 3 in Flush Valves and Toilets
Our Price:
$13.49
FLAPPER TOILET ADJ UNIV 3IN
Our Price:
$14.67
Korky 2023BP Adjustable Universal Toilet Flapper, For Use With 3 in TOTO Toilet Model, Flexible Rubber, Red
Our Price:
$15.81
Plumb Pak PP836-48 Adjustable Toilet Flapper, For Use With Kohler Toilets
Our Price:
$16.24
Plumb Pak K833-2 Chemical Resistant Toilet Tank Flapper, For Use With 3 in American Standard Cadet Flush Valve
Our Price:
$16.31
FLAPPER ULTRA HIGH PERFRMN 3PK
Our Price:
$16.54
Toilet Flapper Korky Tank Ball - Case of 12
Our Price:
$49.92
1